SM Thacker & Associates

Independent Best Practice Training & Consultancy

Home Page Public Training Course Schedules Over 150 Best Practice Articles Expert Systems / Tools This Month's Features / News About Us Your Question / Contact Us
Highlights of our full range of training courses / Workshops:

Lean & Agile Supply Chain / Inventory Modelling

Lean & Agile Manufacturing Planning & Control

Operations Management / Team Leader Training

Step Change Management / Business Process  Reengineering

Continuous Improvement

Procurement (Purchasing & Supplier Management)

IS / IT / e-commerce

Product Management / New Product Introduction  / Quality  Management

 

Bookmarks for this topic below:

Our full range of training

Relevant Training / Workshops

Expert Systems / Tools

Relevant Further Reading

 

Relevant Training Course / In-house Workshop Highlights:

S02 Business Process Reengineering

P03 Service Level Agreements

S13 Culture Development Methods

SSC08 Participative Development, Sales & Operations Management

C01 Focused Improvement Systems

 

Expert Systems / Tools:

Lean & Agile diagnostic checklist

 

Relevant Further Reading: The following further articles were mentioned in this paper:

a. Permanently Maintained Website Articles:

Participative Sales and Operations Planning

Culture Development Methods

E-commerce: E-nabling your business

IS / IT Strategy Software Selection and Implementation

Focused Improvement Systems

Organisational Redesign

Lean & Agile Supply Chains

Lean Manufacturing

Managing Demand

Postponement and Mass Customisation

Agile Manufacturing

Service Level Agreements

Negotiating Software Contracts

b. Previously Featured Articles from our Archives (Up to 2 per organisation available on request):

Previous Best Practices:

B001: Ownership

B002: Education and Training

B003: Procedures and Documentation

B006: Managing Scarce Skills)

B007: Strategic Purchasing

B019: Archiving

 

Previous Techniques:

 

Previous Questions:

 

Previous Malpractices:

 

 

Customer Relationship Management (CRM)

Recognising reality?

Customer Relationships are a key aspect of retaining existing customers and winning new ones. The management of the sales process has and always will be a key success factor. Customer relationships and the need to develop them existed before computer systems. CRM is also a new TLA (three-letter acronym) for the record.

Links to related training and further reading on left

So what are the important aspects of managing customer relationships. It is of course all the key steps in the sales process as follows:

1 Lead generation )

Plus

Marketing

2 Identifying need )
3 Qualification )
4 Specification (may include customisation of standard products) )
5 Enquiry handling )
6 Cost estimating )
7 Quotation (may require project management for complex bids) )
8 Order close )
9 Sales Order Processing )
10 Delivery (may require project management for complex products / services) )
11 Installation / commissioning (may also require project management) )
12 Servicing / spares / repairs )

 

It is also the management of that process.

To make any sense of this process and to provide prioritisation rules, customers or potential customers (prospects) have to be categorised based on their strategic importance. You need to decide for yourself how, but suffice to say not all customers are equal. You may use turnover, future potential, social-economic groups, etc. Once categorised a method has to exist to maintain categories in the light of changes.

Factors, which may be determined by category, include:

  • Pricing,
  • Delivery specification,
  • Enquiry, Quotation and Order entry target turnaround times,
  • Lead times.

Culture

Order winning criteria or repeat business criteria might include the following, but will almost certainly be mostly influenced by the fact that you show that you care:

  • Empower staff to own problems
  • Quote realistic lead time (see Participative Sales and Operations Planning)
  • Follow up quotations
  • Make estimators responsible for sales
  • Give telephone training (see Culture Development Methods)
  • Measure salespersons performance but be careful about incentives (see Managing Demand)
  • Improve disciplines / controls at all stages to avoid backlogs
  • Analyse lost sales (Measure enquiry to order conversion rate)
  • Cross train staff (See Previous Best Practice B006:Managing Scarce Skills)
  • Give sales training to "office" personnel and service and repair staff
  • Hide your internal complexity from your customer. Recently I was passed around from one department to another until I slammed the phone down in total frustration. This would not happen if staff were cross trained to answer simple questions, and the culture was such that they felt the need to do so. In particular staff should be trained to own the problem such that if they do not know the answer to my question they took my number and rang me back (valuing my time).
  • Kill the old systems
  • Make everyone responsible for marketing.

More information can be found in Culture Development Methods

 

This should lead to:

  • Better all round ability to solve customer's problems
  • Clearer priorities
  • More customer confidence
  • Fewer lost documents and delays
  • A more business-like sales office
  • Better customer communication
  • Visible sales targets
  • Ownership of the process
  • Flexible people to deal with overloads
  • Motivated staff
  • Exploiting the telephone to help sales
  • Better understanding of your competitors

Leading to more sales

However I am very uncomfortable about influencing customer "wants" rather than "needs", or exploiting inexperienced buyers, but it is done superbly by a number of organisations. (Nobody needs jewellery, or half of the stuff they sell in supermarkets, or 3D TV!)

 

Managing the Process

There should be a regular scheduled meeting of the sales office and mobile sales force, with a standard agenda as follows:

Operational issues

  • Special issues
    • Customer situations
    • Product developments
    • Sales campaigns
    • Etc.
  • Review of turnaround times for quotes, enquiries, sales orders etc.
  • Customer follow ups needed
  • Sales calls anticipated (Do not let the salesman visit unarmed with the latest situation about current issues affecting that customer)

Development issues

  • Process Changes
  • Organisation changes
  • Problem solving
  • Etc.
  • Critique of the sales meeting

These form a major input into the improvement of the process.

 

The Sales Process

There are a number of business processes involved in selling:

Marketing / new product development

Catalogue maintenance

Product file maintenance

Customer file maintenance

Terms of Business maintenance

Service parts list maintenance

Sales material maintenance

Long term contract maintenance

Price list maintenance

Sales forecasting

Lead generation

Sales calling

Enquiry / specification / customisation

Qualification / credit checking

ITT / bid handling

Estimating

Project management of bids or product development

Quotation management

Contracts

Service Level Agreements

Negotiating Contracts

Credit control

Delivery / installation

Service, spares and repairs management

Order processing

Order acknowledgement

Configuring / application engineering / design

Process planning

Production planning

Progressing work

Cost collection

Allocation of finished goods / parts

Picking

Assembly of components

Packaging

Inventory recording

Despatch

Export documentation

Invoicing

Distribution

Transport and shipping

Commissioning / installation

Warranty

Help desk / complaint handling

 

The relative importance of these processes and appropriate techniques for managing them will vary for different situations. The main criteria being the manufacturing / operations strategy. These vary as shown below:

  • Make for stock
  • Assemble / customise / install and commission standard products to order from standard components
  • Make to order (Bespoke products to customers' specification)
  • Engineer to order (Design and produce)
  • Repair / overhaul / servicing

For each of these processes which are relevant to your business there should exist:

  • An owner (See Previous Best Practice B001: Ownership)
  • A procedure (See Previous Best Practice B003: Procedures and Documentation)
  • A skill matrix (See Previous Best Practice B006: Managing Scarce Skills)
  • A training programme to ensure that continuity is provided (See Previous Best Practice B002: Education and Training)
  • An archive procedure (See Previous Best Practice B019: Archiving)
  • A control system to ensure it is relevant, accurate, and timely

 

There is further detailed information on common operational aspects of the sales and marketing processes in the article E-commerce: E-nabling your business.

 

Modern trends in customer / supplier relationships

The following aspects of these relationships are changing:

There is now a broad recognition that co-operative rather than adversarial relationships are much more productive. For more information on these and other important aspects you should read the following articles:

  1. Lean & Agile Supply Chains
  2. Lean Manufacturing
  3. Managing Demand
  4. Postponement and Mass Customisation
  5. "Strategic Purchasing" (Previous Best Practice B007: Strategic Purchasing)
  6. Agile Manufacturing

 

Customer Perception Analysis

My first exposure to this was when I worked for a computer bureau in the 1980's. They actually rang their main customers every week to ask them for their views of the service. And they acted every week on what the customer said. Up-time for that computer system was 99.99% over a six-month period.

Customer Intelligence

This is not trying to instil intelligence in your customers. It is actively engaging them in conversation at every available opportunity to find out what they are doing, and in particular what problems they are having and what opportunities may exist for you in the future. This is sometimes called continuous marketing as opposed to campaign marketing, which is a one off exercise. It is not selling, it is asking. All your employees who come into contact with customers can do it. There is a significant amount of information gathered about customers during the course of an ongoing relationship, and that includes the despatch clerk, talking to the goods inwards clerk at the other end.

Payment methods

Alternatives to the traditional methods of payment are now commonly employed. These include:

  • Payment on use rather than payment on receipt
  • Self billing
  • Bank transfers
  • Credit card

Communications methods are changing. These now include:

  • Direct ordering
  • Telephone / credit card ordering
  • Fax
  • Email
  • EDI
  • Call centres
  • Top up point of use

Measurement and Reporting

Whilst measurement and reporting is now commonplace, it often leads to "data overload", where there is too much data and no analysis and action arising from it. This topic is covered in Focused Improvement Systems

Logistics methods now include:

  • Deliver to point of use
  • 3rd Party warehousing
  • Carriers
  • Returnable packaging for demand intelligence and production use
  • Milk round collection of supplies
  • Push and Pull methods of stock control

 

Office organisations

These are now being aligned to customer needs with:

  • Customer facing processes
  • Natural Groups
  • Flexible working hours and locations

For example the goals of marketing, sales and service / spares are actually the same when viewed in the long term. However in the short-term conflicts often arise. This balance needs to be flexed as necessary.

My phone call above should not have been frustrating if all of the staff who lived in a department could answer all questions.

 

Self-certification of quality

This means that inspection is no longer necessary.

 

OK it is now 1250 words into this topic and we feel the need to mention tools for aiding this process. Collecting, collating, measuring, analysing, acting and controlling these activities is a time consuming process.

But first the process itself:

 

Business Process Re-engineering

Before automating any process the process itself needs to be designed with the objective of making it firstly effective and secondly efficient. The technique to do this is Business Process Re-engineering or BPR, described in the article Organisational Redesign. Ideally the output of this exercise should be a process which is simple, effective and uses the appropriate tools to do the job. This may include computer systems. Indeed there are now a number of computer software packages, utilities, service providers, "call-centres", and web authors aimed at this process. Dealing with each of these in turn:

Software

1. Sales Lead Management

I evaluated my first sales lead tracking system in 1990, so this is not new. But there is a now a wide range of software aimed at the tracking ("workflow") of a potential client through to order closure and beyond. This software typically includes functions to support the following:

  • Personal contact details
  • Source of lead (Telesales, mail-shot etc.)
  • Company / organisation / network details
  • Sales activity planning (Milestones planning (workflow) /responsibilities and achievement)
  • Diary and activity history (promises / requests made)
  • Reminders based on diary
  • Proposal preparation
  • Event management features such as attendees, no shows, follow-ups
  • Support for mail-shots (literature fulfilment) pre-formatted quotations and other lead generation techniques
  • The management of the campaign process
  • Links to MS Office

Reporting will include:

  • Mining techniques to discover buying patterns and changes in buying patterns
  • Report on diarized events, activity or inactivity of leads, or salespersons and conversion rates
  • Sales milestones management, and source of lead analysis to assess the success of sales methods
  • Ad-hoc reports

 

Typically ERP type systems take over at the point of sales order entry. However, it is desirable to monitor customers throughout their sales life for example to measure cumulative sales value. The equation, cost of sales verses income, cannot be calculated without this. If you also include soft information about potential clients such as motivations and behaviours, you need to be aware of the legal implications. The aim is to make all information available for decision making. In particular information from sales, marketing and service / repair production and stocks is necessary.

So the interface at this point needs to be thought through.

 

2. Marketing Management

Software functions include:

  • Survey generation
  • Survey feedback data entry
  • Analysis, correlation and database mining tools
  • Links to sales lead management, MS office tools

 

3. Telesales

Software functions include:

  • Decision tables and supporting scripts
  • Call plans
  • Power dialling
  • Links to mail-shot
  • Some aspects of help desk below are also relevant to some call centres.

 

4. E-tailing

Software functions include:

  • Web based analysis tools
  • Links to email
  • On line ordering:
    • Shopping cart
    • High security credit card links
    • The last person to order this also was interested in.....
  • Order acknowledgement (email etc.)
  • Links to back office systems / ERP etc.

You will also need web design tools at this point.

 

5. Service / help desk / call centre

Software functions include:

  • Time based incident logging / tracking
  • Caller (name / reference)
  • Call up caller background information such as environment, products in use, previous problems (last 3 calls) etc.
  • Self service option / routing selection
  • Priority
  • Impact
  • Description of question / problem
  • Routing: owner / technical expert / workflow
  • Circumvention documentation (to enable learning)
  • Circumventions
  • Fix documentation (to enable learning)
  • Fixes
  • History (knowledge bases) of previous problems and their cures and search facilities to find them
  • Repeats (This may lead to improving documentation, procedures or product design)
  • Reminders
    • based on scheduled service intervals
    • based on end of life / warranty period
    • based on escalation rules
    • e-mail shots / mail shots

Reporting includes statistics on:

  • Daily, weekly, monthly overall performance and individual performance
  • Escalation reporting by exception (time lapse / severity)
  • You may not like them, but dominant software players provide a useful service here in providing de facto software integration standards.

 

Other factors in software selection

Function is not the overriding criteria for software selection, (although you are unlikely to buy software that does not match your needs). You also need to consider:

  • The supplier
  • Technical aspects
  • Utilities including reporting and query tools

(See IS / IT Strategy Software Selection and Implementation)

 

Utilities

The ability to hold different data from different sources and to be able to analyse it and produce reports, is still a significant challenge to IT. However "Data Warehouses" (large capacity databases), and "Data mining" (searching and sorting capabilities) have now reached reasonable maturity which enables characteristics analysis and correlations to be performed. Algorithms that are useful for mining include:

  1. Correlation (If they buy this are they likely to also buy that?)
  2. Sorting / Grouping (From a set of data what are the natural groups / subgroups?)
  3. Knowledge bases (From previously established rules derived by experts, will this population...., or how much will this population?)
  4. Forecasting (Extrapolating from previous history what is the likely outcome of.....?)

Expert systems (based on collective expert knowledge and learned experience) are still not common but would answer the question: From my experience in a population who is most likely to.....?), This is similar to 3 above except that new knowledge and experience adapt the behaviour of the system, whereas in 3 the knowledge or rules are static.

These tools enable targeting of sales effort.

Service Providers

We now seem to be going full circle back to computer bureau to provide Internet access. There are lots of them. The difficulty here is picking the companies with staying power.

Call Centres

There is now a growing number of call centres to provide centralised telephony such as help desk type services, first line problem solving, selling and Internet responses. These can operate internal or sub-contract services on behalf of clients.

Web authoring

This is now a modern cottage industry.

 

Finally

It is now well understood that over-reacting to complaints creates a better impression than getting it right in the first place. I am not suggesting you should aim to fail but my experience suggests that the occasional crisis to which you over-react, actually creates a great deal of good will. Customers occasionally exploit this, but it is also well understood that it takes far less effort to retain an existing customer than to win a new one.

_________________________________________________

Bookmarks for this topic above:

Our full range of training

Relevant Training / Workshops

Expert Systems / Tools

Relevant Further Reading

Top

To discuss your consulting or training needs with one of our independent consultants or trainers please Contact Us

Home Page Public Training Course Schedules Over 150 Best Practice Articles Expert Systems / Tools This Month's Features / News About Us Your Question / Contact Us

Think Differently!

Whilst great care has been taken to provide relevant, accurate, practical, advice based on our considerable process design and development experience, this will almost certainly require interpretation into the context of your unique business. Please be careful in doing so and if in doubt seek expert advice. We would welcome your feedback!

© SM Thacker & Associates 2010

Code of Ethics

Bottom Line